The Real Trade War
China and Japan hold the most U.S. Treasuries of any country. This is because they both use the same economic model:
- Decrease workers’ ability to collectively organize.
- Decrease the national currency so that productivity gains flow to industrialists and the nation in the form of offshore dollar income.
- Decreased currency makes goods cheap, so developed countries can continue to move production of goods to other countries.
It’s a simple “Asia” economic model. The competition between the major Asian exporters at this stage is mainly over price, and the price is largely determined by the value of each country’s currency. As a result, the Chinese and Japanese care more about the CNY/JPY cross than the cross of their currencies against the U.S. dollar.
So who is the most price competitive nation right now?
The spread between USD/JPY and USD/CNY:
I have indexed the USD/CNY and USD/JPY exchange rate at 100 since January 1, 2009. To June 12, 2023. As you can see, the JPY weakened by about 50% more than the CNY over the same period. But perhaps most notable is the fact that the spread between these two assets has widened significantly since COVID.
I have added CNY/KRW (Chinese yuan vs. South Korean yuan) and CNY/EUR below to complete the competitive environment of global exporters. The CNY/EUR pair essentially values Germany as the main EU economy.
China is 3% cheaper than Korea, but 25% more expensive than Germany, using this simple metric.
It makes perfect sense that the yen depreciated so dramatically against the yuan. The Bank of Japan continued to print more and more money, trying to keep the yield on Japanese government bonds at a certain level. This is called yield curve control (YCC). Since COVID, China has not yet been printing money or issuing credit to such an extent as to artificially tie bond yields to a certain level. So it makes sense that the JPY has weakened against the CNY by 46% since 2009.
CNY/JPY cross rate:
Chinese goods are more expensive than Japanese. Exports have been affected, and the latest data confirm this.
China’s export growth year over year:
The main blow from the COVID lockdowns began in summer 2022 – the chart above shows that exports collapsed just then. Then Beijing abandoned the Zero COVID policy and reopened. Exports rose again as people went back to work. This trajectory from decline to rise has masked a general weakening of the global consumer and a decline in the price competitiveness of Chinese goods.
The China Manufacturing Business Activity Index >50 points, <50 points:
This chart shows the same story as exports
China is now fully open, and the 2022 quarantine should have no lasting effects. However, exports are now falling year on year. This is not good.. And while all this was going on, the JPY weakened a lot against the CNY. If the global pie is shrinking, China needs to become more competitive with its major export competitors to maintain the growth needed to appease its population. Its number one competitor is Japan (remember, they have the same economic models). The yuan MUST weaken against the yen to help China grow.
The biggest reason the Chinese Communist Party needs to grow is because they have a huge unemployment problem.. In particular, unemployment among urban youth exceeds 20%. There are simply not enough jobs for high school and university graduates.
The unemployment rate among Chinese urban youth ages 15-24:
For those of you who do not know: graduating from university in China is important because it is very difficult to get in. High school students take what is called the GaoKao (literal translation: “big test”). If you don’t score high enough, you won’t get into university. China has no preferences for athletes. Therefore, children and parents are completely focused on this test from the moment they enter elementary school. How do you think an employer in such a big country evaluates who to hire and who not to hire? He looks at things like test scores and university grades. It works even harder here than in the West.
For the past 40 years, parents who have spent all their energy and money on educating their only little emperor through the school system have been more than rewarded. University graduates got jobs with higher pay than manual, monotonous factory work. They would move to the city and get a hukou (residence permit). Success!
But now, having spent the liveliness and fun of childhood studying nonsense, you graduate from university and don’t get a job. China has a huge underclass of extremely educated and talented young people. It is literally the Marxist’s worst nightmare to believe that the intellectual bourgeoisie can sow the seeds of revolution if it is not stopped. Xi Jinping is a disciple of Mao and certainly understands that his party must create jobs so that young people can return to work.
When in doubt, China resorts to policies supporting exports and infrastructure projects to stimulate growth and employment. The supply-side economic measures that got China to where it is today are likely to be repeated, even if it means accumulating new debt on an already gigantic pile of. This requires a weaker yuan.
To weaken the currency, the NBK will stimulate credit growth in “good” sectors of the economy. Semiconductors, artificial intelligence, clean energy, real estate, etc.. д. will have higher credit quotes. Banks will be instructed to lend a certain amount in yuan to these sectors or something else. It doesn’t matter if these businesses really need capital.
As credit expands, the currency will be allowed to weaken. The NBK could implement a one-time shock devaluation and then slowly steer the Chinese yuan downward, weakening it against the yen over time.
Chinese producer PPI (white) and CPI (yellow) indices:
Since both PPI and CPI are on a negative path, the NBK could soften without fear of spurring inflation.
Since some of this capital is not needed by high-end firms, it will “trickle down” into financial assets (much the same way it happened with subsidies for wealthy Americans). There are various ways in which companies that are supposed to produce gadgets end up with loans and use them to speculate on financial asset markets. And most importantly for this essay, masses of wealthy Chinese – who see disaster coming – will begin to move capital out of China.
In the past, the People’s Bank of China may have worried about capital flight, but the stock of Western fiat financial assets “owned” by China has become a liability rather than an asset. It’s because the West has gone from friend to foe. Who knows what will happen in Western political circles regarding Chinese capital. It is quite possible that one day we will all wake up and see that some of China’s assets have been frozen because of some action that has displeased Western political elites.
Whether you are a democratically elected president, dictator or emperor, politics is about covering your ass (CYA, cover your ass). How does the CYA party treat China’s state-owned foreign assets? It allows the rich to exchange yuan for dollars and buy goods. And if a rich Chinese man is ever robbed of his New York mansion because he is a rich non-white foreigner, that is his problem, not the Party’s.
China’s foreign exchange reserves (in millions. dollars):
As you can see, China has a “problem” of about $3 trillion.
An even better policy would be to let the rich buy hard assets, like cryptocurrency. And then ensure that they are kept in China by the trustees they control or own. I predicted, and continue to believe, that Hong Kong will become the conduit through which Chinese capital will be allowed to own crypto-financial assets. When I say financial assets, I mean ownership of the financial proceeds of the underlying crypto-tokens or currencies. It will probably be done through funds or derivatives, because Beijing has no interest in allowing its voters to actually own technology that provides real economic freedom that is not backed by the state. So Chinese investors are selling the fiat dogshit on the state’s balance sheet and replacing it with bitcoins and other cryptocurrencies. The Chinese nation, seen as one, will have a stronger balance sheet after such actions.
This is how I envision such a flow working:
- Hong Kong allows various asset managers to offer exchange-traded funds (ETFs) backed by cryptocurrency. As an example, take the Bitcoin ETF.
- A Chinese investor somehow converts CNY into Hong Kong dollars (HKD). It can’t be difficult – otherwise the Hong Kong real estate market wouldn’t be so buoyant.
- Then a Chinese investor buys one of the Bitcoin ETFs listed on the Hong Kong Stock Exchange.
- The ETF manager buys physical bitcoin in the global market, which is then held by a local licensed custodian in Hong Kong.
- The Chinese investor now owns the ETF, which is a bitcoin derivative, but not physical bitcoin. The investor can only participate in Bitcoin price changes, not own the coin itself.
This solves many problems for China:
- Gives access to a hard asset for wealthy Chinese who want to avoid the continued weakening of the Chinese yuan. The rich feel smart and satisfied that their capital is “protected.”
- The end point of such an exit would be an institution that must follow any rules set by Hong Kong regulators. In essence, this means that physical bitcoins are controlled by the Chinese government. This is no different than how bitcoin held in any U.S. registered ETF or trust fund is ultimately controlled by the U.S. government. Capitalism or communism is one and the same.
- This reduces the amount of Western fiat assets owned by the Chinese state. When a wealthy Chinese investor sells CNY and buys HKD, the National Bank of China takes the other side and buys CNY and sells HKD, which is essentially the US dollar because of its peg. The National Bank can carry out these transactions because of the large amount of assets in dollars that China has. Refer to the chart above depicting the $3 trillion piggy bank.
For us cryptohoppers, this is a great result. The return of a Chinese cryptotrader through Hong Kong’s financial tubes will revive the market. In the meantime, America’s broke masses will be effectively shut out of crypto. The beauty is that each state’s actions encourage the other country to do the same.
The simple act of China weakening its currency and allowing loyal comrades to buy bitcoin derivatives in return reduces the amount of Western fiat assets the country owns. The more reluctant China is to buy U.S. Treasuries with its export earnings or hold assets in dollars in any form, the harder the states must work to ensure that the capital of its citizens cannot leave Sharpe World as the usual buyer of long-term debt, China, strikes. This is a positive-reflexive relationship that should bring glorious profits to Lord Satoshi’s loyalists.